Discussion Closed This discussion was created more than 6 months ago and has been closed. To start a new discussion with a link back to this one, click here.
Permanent magnet machine modelling!
Posted 17 nov 2009, 04:52 GMT-5 8 Replies
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
I am simulating a permanent magnet generator, in 2D Comsol, 'emqa', 'ALE' mode. But there is a problem concerning magnetic circuit saturation as the followings:
- My programs are convergent with linear permeability, but converge in some cases
- In static mode, there are no problems; my program is convergent with any types of BH curves (using analytical function of BH curve or piecewise line or table).
- While generator is no load, my program is not convergent with BH curve using table interpolation; even BH curve is made so smoothly and corrects the natural of physical.
But my program converges with a few analytical functions, not all; if analytical function of BH is identical to measured BH curve, my program does not work.
- While generator operates with load, having electric current in winding, my program is not convergent. Even I operated my program in right way: first run with linear permeability, and then...However, if the remanent flux density of magnet is reduced to certain value, e.g (Br=0.8T), my program is convergent. It is so strange!
I also discussed with my colleagues using other FEM soft wares; it seems like having the same problem. Are there any limitations of FEM-softwares?
I would like to receive suggestion from Comsol experts.
Thanks in advance.
- My programs are convergent with linear permeability, but converge in some cases
- In static mode, there are no problems; my program is convergent with any types of BH curves (using analytical function of BH curve or piecewise line or table).
- While generator is no load, my program is not convergent with BH curve using table interpolation; even BH curve is made so smoothly and corrects the natural of physical.
But my program converges with a few analytical functions, not all; if analytical function of BH is identical to measured BH curve, my program does not work.
- While generator operates with load, having electric current in winding, my program is not convergent. Even I operated my program in right way: first run with linear permeability, and then...However, if the remanent flux density of magnet is reduced to certain value, e.g (Br=0.8T), my program is convergent. It is so strange!
I also discussed with my colleagues using other FEM soft wares; it seems like having the same problem. Are there any limitations of FEM-softwares?
I would like to receive suggestion from Comsol experts.
Thanks in advance.
8 Replies Last Post 15 mag 2013, 07:46 GMT-4
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
2 decades ago
Hi
Difficult to give a clear answers, but I do not beleive it's any limitation related to the FEM as such, it hears more like a "stepping" issue for the non-linear solver.
Have you tried to select "highly non linear" in the solver tab ? and read carefully through the manuals on solver settings for non-linear solving ?
Try to understand how the solver si moving along your non linear curves, probably it's stepping to quickly and does no get to follow the gradients of your curves.
Good luck
Ivar
Difficult to give a clear answers, but I do not beleive it's any limitation related to the FEM as such, it hears more like a "stepping" issue for the non-linear solver.
Have you tried to select "highly non linear" in the solver tab ? and read carefully through the manuals on solver settings for non-linear solving ?
Try to understand how the solver si moving along your non linear curves, probably it's stepping to quickly and does no get to follow the gradients of your curves.
Good luck
Ivar
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
2 decades ago
Dear Hung,
Please run the model that does not converge again and send me the
surface plots of normB and of mur that you obtain at the last computed
solution. Based on previous experience, I expect that the value for
normB becomes too high and the the value for mur becomes too low
in certain regions of the geometry. I would like to see whether we can
solve the non-convergence using either a finer mesh or by rounding
sharp corners in the domain (using fillet). The fact that the simulation
does work for the permanent magnets included in the model can be
possibly due to the fact the field of the permanent magnets prevents
the values of normB becomming too large. So, please send me the two
figures.
Best, Domenico.
Please run the model that does not converge again and send me the
surface plots of normB and of mur that you obtain at the last computed
solution. Based on previous experience, I expect that the value for
normB becomes too high and the the value for mur becomes too low
in certain regions of the geometry. I would like to see whether we can
solve the non-convergence using either a finer mesh or by rounding
sharp corners in the domain (using fillet). The fact that the simulation
does work for the permanent magnets included in the model can be
possibly due to the fact the field of the permanent magnets prevents
the values of normB becomming too large. So, please send me the two
figures.
Best, Domenico.
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
2 decades ago
Hi,
Thanks for your useful information. I took some time to play with it and will try more.
Thanks again.
Hung
Thanks for your useful information. I took some time to play with it and will try more.
Thanks again.
Hung
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
2 decades ago
Hi Domenico,
Thanks for your information. I am collecting that you required and will send you as soon as possible.
Regards, Hung
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
1 decade ago
Hi All,
i have quite the same problem.
and looking forward to hear from the experts
regards
akmal
i have quite the same problem.
and looking forward to hear from the experts
regards
akmal
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
1 decade ago
Hi,
With Comsol version 3.5a or newer, you can solve nonlinear transient problem of a permanent magnet machine efficiently. Let try with different solvers to find good one.
Good luck.
Hung.
With Comsol version 3.5a or newer, you can solve nonlinear transient problem of a permanent magnet machine efficiently. Let try with different solvers to find good one.
Good luck.
Hung.
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
1 decade ago
Hello Hung,
I met the same problems as yours. I am wondering whether you have solved these problems.
One interesting thing is that my problem is not convergent with HB curve in stationary study while you have finished on it. Would you mind to share your steps with me? Thank you in advance.
Best regards,
Xuezhou
I met the same problems as yours. I am wondering whether you have solved these problems.
One interesting thing is that my problem is not convergent with HB curve in stationary study while you have finished on it. Would you mind to share your steps with me? Thank you in advance.
Best regards,
Xuezhou
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
1 decade ago
Hello Domenico,
I guess these are the same problems I met with. However, Hung made it converge with any type of BH curve in stationary case while I failed. How about the progress on this issue?
Look forward to your reply. Thanks in advance.
Best regards,
Xuezhou
I guess these are the same problems I met with. However, Hung made it converge with any type of BH curve in stationary case while I failed. How about the progress on this issue?
Look forward to your reply. Thanks in advance.
Best regards,
Xuezhou