Menu

Discussion Forum

New Discussion
Filtra

Discussion Closed This discussion was created more than 6 months ago and has been closed. To start a new discussion with a link back to this one, click here.

Error "Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero"

Posted 25 mag 2011, 16:50 GMT-4 Modeling Tools & Definitions, Parameters, Variables, & Functions Version 5.2 13 Replies

Xiaoyi Yu
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

The error is as follows:

Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero.
- Function: ^
Failed to evaluate expression.
- Expression: d(d((-(mod1.fct-(Tm-mod1.T)*switch(t/unit_s_cf)*mod1.fc^(2/3)/unit_K_cf)*test(mod1.fc))*(dvol),{test@2}),mod1.fc)

In the expression, the only place that contain the function ^ is fc^(2/3). In the model, the fc can be zero, but why the error is "Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero." ? The power is 2/3, why comsol treat it as negative?
13 Replies Last Post 16 dic 2016, 11:39 GMT-5
J Yuan
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 21 giu 2011, 07:33 GMT-4
i meet the same error when dealing with a discontinuse function
i meet the same error when dealing with a discontinuse function
Alexis Grenier
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 27 lug 2011, 00:21 GMT-4
I have the same problem.

I think COMSOL wants to derive this equation. If you derive x^(2/3) the results is (2/3)x^(-1/3) so there is a negative power.

I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please?




Alexis
I have the same problem. I think COMSOL wants to derive this equation. If you derive x^(2/3) the results is (2/3)x^(-1/3) so there is a negative power. I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please? Alexis
Michael Rembe Certified Consultant
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 27 lug 2011, 02:48 GMT-4
May be there is an expression that becomes negative. Check your expressions!

In some cases there are expressions that should be zero. But because of numerical effects they get a very small negative value. That may cause this error. In this cases you can add 'eps', a very small number, to your expression. May be, it helps.

Michael
May be there is an expression that becomes negative. Check your expressions! In some cases there are expressions that should be zero. But because of numerical effects they get a very small negative value. That may cause this error. In this cases you can add 'eps', a very small number, to your expression. May be, it helps. Michael
Nina Wilkens
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 27 lug 2011, 07:02 GMT-4
Hi,
I always had this error, when the initial values (start field) where too far off from the solution. It had nothing to do with the expression being zero, as I had added a small value to stop it from becoming zero. I managed to avoid this error by first solving a simpler problem (without the power 2/3 maybe?) and then using the solution as the start field.
Hope this helps,
Nina
Hi, I always had this error, when the initial values (start field) where too far off from the solution. It had nothing to do with the expression being zero, as I had added a small value to stop it from becoming zero. I managed to avoid this error by first solving a simpler problem (without the power 2/3 maybe?) and then using the solution as the start field. Hope this helps, Nina
Xiaoyi Yu
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 27 lug 2011, 08:35 GMT-4

I have the same problem.

I think COMSOL wants to derive this equation. If you derive x^(2/3) the results is (2/3)x^(-1/3) so there is a negative power.

I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please?




Alexis


Your are right. In my model, the initial value of fc is zero, so I just plus an very small number eps, and it worked.
[QUOTE] I have the same problem. I think COMSOL wants to derive this equation. If you derive x^(2/3) the results is (2/3)x^(-1/3) so there is a negative power. I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please? Alexis [/QUOTE] Your are right. In my model, the initial value of fc is zero, so I just plus an very small number eps, and it worked.
Alexis Grenier
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 27 lug 2011, 22:03 GMT-4
I want to create a plastic law : k*(solid.epe^n) where k,n are constants and solid.epe is the plastic strain.

I have tried with k*((solid.epe+eps)^n), the model computes but when I want to analyse the stress I have the same error message!

Have you any idea?


Alexis
I want to create a plastic law : k*(solid.epe^n) where k,n are constants and solid.epe is the plastic strain. I have tried with k*((solid.epe+eps)^n), the model computes but when I want to analyse the stress I have the same error message! Have you any idea? Alexis
Xiaoyi Yu
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 28 lug 2011, 09:12 GMT-4

I want to create a plastic law : k*(solid.epe^n) where k,n are constants and solid.epe is the plastic strain.

I have tried with k*((solid.epe+eps)^n), the model computes but when I want to analyse the stress I have the same error message!

Have you any idea?


Alexis


I don't know much about your model. You said your model can run, but during the postprocessing, the error occurred. What's the expression of the stress?
[QUOTE] I want to create a plastic law : k*(solid.epe^n) where k,n are constants and solid.epe is the plastic strain. I have tried with k*((solid.epe+eps)^n), the model computes but when I want to analyse the stress I have the same error message! Have you any idea? Alexis [/QUOTE] I don't know much about your model. You said your model can run, but during the postprocessing, the error occurred. What's the expression of the stress?
Alexis Grenier
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 9 ago 2011, 20:37 GMT-4
Thanks for your answer, I have succeed to create my plastic law by studying the COMSOL model: elastoplastic_plate.

Cheers,

Alexis
Thanks for your answer, I have succeed to create my plastic law by studying the COMSOL model: elastoplastic_plate. Cheers, Alexis
Quang Tuyen Tran
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 18 set 2011, 03:24 GMT-4
Hello everyone,

I had the same problem, you can see my problem:

Failed to find consistent initial values.
Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero.
Function: ^
Failed to evaluate expression.
Expression: d(d((up(mod1.nitf.rho)*up(mod1.nitf.Cp)*mod1.nitf.C mu^0.25*sqrt(max(mod1.k,0))*if(down(try catch(mod1.nitf.mu,-1))!=-1,(up(mod1.T)-down(mod1.T))*down(test(mod1.T)),(down(mod1.T)-up(mod1.T))*up(test(mod1.T)))/mod1.nitf.Tplus)*(dvol),{if@21}),mod1.k)
Last time step is not converged.

The initial of mu is not zero, it is the density of the material Air, and PE.
I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please?


Hello everyone, I had the same problem, you can see my problem: Failed to find consistent initial values. Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero. Function: ^ Failed to evaluate expression. Expression: d(d((up(mod1.nitf.rho)*up(mod1.nitf.Cp)*mod1.nitf.C mu^0.25*sqrt(max(mod1.k,0))*if(down(try catch(mod1.nitf.mu,-1))!=-1,(up(mod1.T)-down(mod1.T))*down(test(mod1.T)),(down(mod1.T)-up(mod1.T))*up(test(mod1.T)))/mod1.nitf.Tplus)*(dvol),{if@21}),mod1.k) Last time step is not converged. The initial of mu is not zero, it is the density of the material Air, and PE. I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please?
Xiaoyi Yu
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 18 set 2011, 11:13 GMT-4

Hello everyone,

I had the same problem, you can see my problem:

Failed to find consistent initial values.
Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero.
Function: ^
Failed to evaluate expression.
Expression: d(d((up(mod1.nitf.rho)*up(mod1.nitf.Cp)*mod1.nitf.C mu^0.25*sqrt(max(mod1.k,0))*if(down(try catch(mod1.nitf.mu,-1))!=-1,(up(mod1.T)-down(mod1.T))*down(test(mod1.T)),(down(mod1.T)-up(mod1.T))*up(test(mod1.T)))/mod1.nitf.Tplus)*(dvol),{if@21}),mod1.k)
Last time step is not converged.

The initial of mu is not zero, it is the density of the material Air, and PE.
I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please?


There is only one ^ in your expression, try "mu+eps" to see whether it works or not.
[QUOTE] Hello everyone, I had the same problem, you can see my problem: Failed to find consistent initial values. Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero. Function: ^ Failed to evaluate expression. Expression: d(d((up(mod1.nitf.rho)*up(mod1.nitf.Cp)*mod1.nitf.C mu^0.25*sqrt(max(mod1.k,0))*if(down(try catch(mod1.nitf.mu,-1))!=-1,(up(mod1.T)-down(mod1.T))*down(test(mod1.T)),(down(mod1.T)-up(mod1.T))*up(test(mod1.T)))/mod1.nitf.Tplus)*(dvol),{if@21}),mod1.k) Last time step is not converged. The initial of mu is not zero, it is the density of the material Air, and PE. I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please? [/QUOTE] There is only one ^ in your expression, try "mu+eps" to see whether it works or not.
Chaney Long
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 19 lug 2013, 16:27 GMT-4


Hello everyone,

I had the same problem, you can see my problem:

Failed to find consistent initial values.
Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero.
Function: ^
Failed to evaluate expression.
Expression: d(d((up(mod1.nitf.rho)*up(mod1.nitf.Cp)*mod1.nitf.C mu^0.25*sqrt(max(mod1.k,0))*if(down(try catch(mod1.nitf.mu,-1))!=-1,(up(mod1.T)-down(mod1.T))*down(test(mod1.T)),(down(mod1.T)-up(mod1.T))*up(test(mod1.T)))/mod1.nitf.Tplus)*(dvol),{if@21}),mod1.k)
Last time step is not converged.

The initial of mu is not zero, it is the density of the material Air, and PE.
I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please?


There is only one ^ in your expression, try "mu+eps" to see whether it works or not.




Hi,

Have you guys solved this typical problem? I am always caught this problem...
[QUOTE] [QUOTE] Hello everyone, I had the same problem, you can see my problem: Failed to find consistent initial values. Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero. Function: ^ Failed to evaluate expression. Expression: d(d((up(mod1.nitf.rho)*up(mod1.nitf.Cp)*mod1.nitf.C mu^0.25*sqrt(max(mod1.k,0))*if(down(try catch(mod1.nitf.mu,-1))!=-1,(up(mod1.T)-down(mod1.T))*down(test(mod1.T)),(down(mod1.T)-up(mod1.T))*up(test(mod1.T)))/mod1.nitf.Tplus)*(dvol),{if@21}),mod1.k) Last time step is not converged. The initial of mu is not zero, it is the density of the material Air, and PE. I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please? [/QUOTE] There is only one ^ in your expression, try "mu+eps" to see whether it works or not. [/QUOTE] Hi, Have you guys solved this typical problem? I am always caught this problem...
Chaney Long
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 19 lug 2013, 16:29 GMT-4

Thanks for your answer, I have succeed to create my plastic law by studying the COMSOL model: elastoplastic_plate.

Cheers,

Alexis


Hi Alex,

Thanks a lot for your mentioning this model for the self define plastic model, but have you tried self define flow rule in your own plastic law in comsol?

Thanks.
Chaney

[QUOTE] Thanks for your answer, I have succeed to create my plastic law by studying the COMSOL model: elastoplastic_plate. Cheers, Alexis [/QUOTE] Hi Alex, Thanks a lot for your mentioning this model for the self define plastic model, but have you tried self define flow rule in your own plastic law in comsol? Thanks. Chaney
João Santos
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 8 years ago 16 dic 2016, 11:39 GMT-5


I have the same problem.

I think COMSOL wants to derive this equation. If you derive x^(2/3) the results is (2/3)x^(-1/3) so there is a negative power.

I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please?




Alexis


Your are right. In my model, the initial value of fc is zero, so I just plus an very small number eps, and it worked.


Xiaoyi Yu,

I'm having the same problem to model an adsorption column using Freundlich isotherm. My initial value of u1 is zero. Could you give me some help?

Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero.
- Function: ^
Failed to evaluate expression.
- Expression: dvol*(-(-(((c0*(n*((comp1.u1*c0)^(n-1))))*KF)*(1/q0))))
Failed to evaluate Jacobian of expression.
- Expression: dvol*(-(((comp1.u2*S)+comp1.u2t)-((((comp1.u1*c0)^n)*KF)/q0)))
Failed to evaluate Jacobian of expression.
- Expression: (-(comp1.u2t+S*comp1.u2-KF*(c0*comp1.u1)^n/q0)*test(comp1.u2))*(dvol)
- Feature: Time-Dependent Solver 1 (sol1/t1)

Regards,

João
[QUOTE] [QUOTE] I have the same problem. I think COMSOL wants to derive this equation. If you derive x^(2/3) the results is (2/3)x^(-1/3) so there is a negative power. I don't find a way to solve this problem, if you succeed can you say me how you did please? Alexis [/QUOTE] Your are right. In my model, the initial value of fc is zero, so I just plus an very small number eps, and it worked. [/QUOTE] Xiaoyi Yu, I'm having the same problem to model an adsorption column using Freundlich isotherm. My initial value of u1 is zero. Could you give me some help? Attempt to evaluate negative power of zero. - Function: ^ Failed to evaluate expression. - Expression: dvol*(-(-(((c0*(n*((comp1.u1*c0)^(n-1))))*KF)*(1/q0)))) Failed to evaluate Jacobian of expression. - Expression: dvol*(-(((comp1.u2*S)+comp1.u2t)-((((comp1.u1*c0)^n)*KF)/q0))) Failed to evaluate Jacobian of expression. - Expression: (-(comp1.u2t+S*comp1.u2-KF*(c0*comp1.u1)^n/q0)*test(comp1.u2))*(dvol) - Feature: Time-Dependent Solver 1 (sol1/t1) Regards, João

Note that while COMSOL employees may participate in the discussion forum, COMSOL® software users who are on-subscription should submit their questions via the Support Center for a more comprehensive response from the Technical Support team.

Suggested Content